So everyone has a tequila story, right? Whether it happened to you, or someone you know, you probably have at least one story. Last Thursday, in honor of Cinco de Mayo, we had a tequila tasting at work, with Jose Cuervo Especial Silver, Jose Cuervo Tradicional Silver and Camarena Silver being available to taste. So I figured, why not review them here? My only problem is, every tequila I try ultimately gets compared to Corazon Blanco, as it is still my favorite. It’s sweet, but not so sweet that it feels syrupy, and it has just the right amount of spice to remind you that you are indeed drinking tequila. But I shall try to review the three from Cinco de Mayo without letting Corazon cloud my judgment.
Up first is Cuervo Especial Silver. This one was the sweetest of the bunch, but that’s because it’s a mixto, meaning only 51% of it is fermented from the sugars of the agave plant, with the remaining 49% coming from cheaper sugar sources. That being said, it doesn’t have the bite usually associated with tequila and as a mixto, is at the lower end of the price spectrum when compared to other name brand tequilas. As I said, it was the sweetest of the three we had available at the tasting, with it’s taste being similar to sugar cane syrup in both flavor and texture. It tasted good, but felt like I was drinking a liqueur, as opposed to liquor. There is a hint of pepper in the finish, but not enough to scare any tequila newbies away. The smoothness and price make Jose Cuervo Especial Silver a great introduction to tequila for those who’ve held off on trying it because of hearing horror stories about it, since everyone has a tequila story.
Next is Jose Cuervo Tradicional Silver. Unlike Especial Silver, this is a 100% blue agave tequila, meaning 100% of the distillate (distilled liquor before it is cut with water) comes from the blue agave plant. As such, it is a bit spicier than the Especial Silver. The “hint of pepper” that Especial Silver had in it’s finish is now present throughout the entire drinking experience, and it ain’t just a hint anymore, which might discourage those who’ve never had tequila. However, Cuervo Tradicional still retains much of the sweetness of the blue agave and makes a great margarita.
Last, but certainly not least, we tried Camarena Silver. Camarena is an new brand to me, as I had never heard of them until the last month. One sip though, and I thought I might have found a new favorite. It was as sweet as the Cuervo Tradicional, but without the peppery contrast – I was back to having a “hint of pepper”. But unlike Cuervo Especial, no syrupy taste/feel here – there is no mistaking that this is liquor and not liqueur. Add to that the fact that it’s nearly $15 cheaper than Corazon Blanco and I may have found a new go-to tequila. While it isn’t quite as good as Corazon, it is definitely the closest runner-up so far. If Corazon is an A+, Camarena is an A-. I would definitely recommend Camarena over the two Cuervo tequilas we had available for tasting, and I would also recommend it to those looking for an introduction to the world of tequila. I’ve tried silver/white tequilas from Corazon, Patron, Cuervo, Republic (also tried their reposado and anejo), El Jimador, Don Julio, Cabo Wabo, Sauza and 1800, among others, and Camarena beats every one of them (except for Corazon) in my opinion.
Average Prices for a 750ml bottle:
- Jose Cuervo Especial Silver, $22.99
- Jose Cuervo Tradicional Silver, $29.49
- Camarena Silver, $21.49
- Corazon Blanco, $35.99